HughNantucket may be known for its postcard-perfect beaches, charming cobblestone streets, and historic lighthouses, but beyond the popular sights lies a treasure trove of lesser-known locations that offer a more intimate glimpse into island life. Whether you’re a first-time visitor or a seasoned traveler, here are seven hidden gems that will make your Nantucket visit truly unforgettable.
1. Coskata-Coatue Wildlife Refuge
Tucked away on the northeastern tip of Nantucket, this serene nature reserve is a haven for wildlife and a paradise for outdoor lovers. You can only access it via 4WD vehicle or by hiking, but the effort is well worth it. Expect sweeping views, quiet beaches, and the iconic Great Point Lighthouse without the crowds.
2. Lily Pond Park
Just a short walk from downtown Nantucket, Lily Pond Park feels worlds away from the hustle and bustle. With shaded walking trails, wooden boardwalks, and peaceful pond views, it’s a perfect spot for reflection or a quiet picnic.
3. The Old Mill
While it might be on a few tourist maps, the Old Mill is often overlooked in favor of more famous sites. Built in 1746, it’s the oldest functioning windmill in the U.S. and offers a glimpse into Nantucket’s industrious past. Bonus: It’s rarely crowded and makes for great photos.
4. Sconset Bluff Walk
A stunning coastal path that winds behind private homes and gardens in the village of Siasconset (locals call it “Sconset”). The views of the ocean and rose-covered cottages are straight out of a storybook. It’s public access, but still a quiet and magical experience.
5. Something Natural Bakery
Off the beaten path on Cliff Road, this local favorite is housed in a rustic, ivy-covered cottage. Their giant sandwiches and fresh-baked cookies are perfect for a beach picnic, and the surrounding lawn is a peaceful place to enjoy lunch under shady trees.
6. Altar Rock
As one of the highest points on the island, Altar Rock offers panoramic views of Nantucket’s moors and the Atlantic beyond. It’s especially beautiful at sunrise or sunset. Bring your camera—and maybe a sense of adventure to find it!
7. Cisco Brewers
Okay, maybe not exactly “hidden,” but this laid-back, open-air brewery is often missed by visitors who stick to downtown. With live music, food trucks, and a rotating selection of beer, wine, and spirits, it’s a local favorite and a great way to cap off your day.
Final Thoughts
Exploring Nantucket’s hidden gems adds depth and authenticity to any visit. These spots reflect the soul of the island—quiet, beautiful, and full of surprises. When you book with Discover Nantucket Tours, we make sure you don’t just see the island, you experience it.
Ready to explore the real Nantucket? Let’s go check it out together! Discover Nantucket Tours. Book your tour today!
